Glossary entry (derived from question below)
French term or phrase:
take a stand
Spanish translation:
tomar posición
Added to glossary by
María Belanche García
Jan 9, 2019 18:21
5 yrs ago
6 viewers *
French term
take a stand
French to Spanish
Art/Literary
Psychology
Manipulative people
Context:
They doubt their abilities and are excessively afraid to take a stand
My translation: Dudan de sus capacidades y tienen un miedo excesivo a pronunciarse
Note: This phrase has been questioned by a reviewer of my book who stated as follows:
One phrase I found confusing was on Page 30, third paragraph, "Dudan de sus capacidades y tienen un miedo excesivo a pronunciarse." It is an odd way of saying that they have an excessive fear of being found lacking. It translates to “They doubt their abilities and have an excessive fear of pronouncing themselves." Odd but understandable.
Please, can you discuss your reasons against the reviewer's argument that the translation is odd?
Much appreciated!
They doubt their abilities and are excessively afraid to take a stand
My translation: Dudan de sus capacidades y tienen un miedo excesivo a pronunciarse
Note: This phrase has been questioned by a reviewer of my book who stated as follows:
One phrase I found confusing was on Page 30, third paragraph, "Dudan de sus capacidades y tienen un miedo excesivo a pronunciarse." It is an odd way of saying that they have an excessive fear of being found lacking. It translates to “They doubt their abilities and have an excessive fear of pronouncing themselves." Odd but understandable.
Please, can you discuss your reasons against the reviewer's argument that the translation is odd?
Much appreciated!
Proposed translations
(Spanish)
3 | tomar posición | María Belanche García |
Change log
Jan 12, 2019 04:05: María Belanche García Created KOG entry
Proposed translations
13 hrs
Selected
tomar posición
...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "gracias"
Reference comments
17 mins
Reference:
Linguee says you're right:
take a stand = adoptar una postura ; •adoptar una actitud firme ; posicionarse ; pronunciarse
https://www.linguee.com/english-spanish/search?source=auto&q...
take a stand = adoptar una postura ; •adoptar una actitud firme ; posicionarse ; pronunciarse
https://www.linguee.com/english-spanish/search?source=auto&q...
34 mins
Reference:
be found lacking (=be unable to do what is necessary or expected): If someone needed first aid, would you be found lacking? (Macmillan Dictionary)
To take a stand es ciertamente distinto. Tal vez yo habría escrito “a decir lo que piensan”.
Y no me parece normal que el revisor traduzca tu traducción de esa forma.
To take a stand es ciertamente distinto. Tal vez yo habría escrito “a decir lo que piensan”.
Y no me parece normal que el revisor traduzca tu traducción de esa forma.
Discussion
7. prnl. Declararse o mostrarse a favor o en contra de alguien o de algo.
http://dle.rae.es/?id=UMuOmRK
En cuanto a su extraña interpretación de "take a stand", podrías remitirle a:
https://www.linguee.com/english-spanish/search?source=auto&q...